Forums:
Some weird ones. First is, I guess, Opuntia basilaris var. brachyclada (doing the right thing by shriveling) and a mystery opuntia I got from Kelly Grummons which he collected near Briggsdale, Colorado.
Some people have suggested this is O. arenaria, but that grows in Texas.
Neither has ever flowered.
Bob
Comments
Trond Hoy
Re: other cactus
Fri, 12/09/2011 - 6:33amAgree! Would love to have that motif in my own garden :o
I also liked the Cylindropuntia!
Martin Tversted (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sat, 12/10/2011 - 2:14amTrond, cylindropuntias are the tall cacti for our climate. In the unheated greenhouse I have had them to 180 cm.
DesertZone (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sat, 12/10/2011 - 9:40amThat might be a good cactus for over there. I know Cylindropuntia imbricata can handle wet feet here in the winter. I bet if it was high on a mound it would do ok, and if it had some heat for growth in the summer. :)
John P. Weiser
Re: other cactus
Sat, 12/10/2011 - 6:36pmOpuntia chlorotica is an upright shrubby Opuntia from the Mohave and Sonoran deserts. I have been able to grow it in my Garden with no apparent damage for four years now. It is planted about two foot away from my south foundation. This extra warm micro-climate allows it thrive.
http://plants.usda.gov/java/profile?symbol=OPCH
http://www.calflora.org/cgi-bin/species_query.cgi?where-taxon=Opuntia+ch...
http://www.mojavenp.org/opuntia_chlorotica_mojave_national_preserve.htm
http://www.efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id=1&taxon_id=242415191
DesertZone (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sat, 12/10/2011 - 10:27pmJohn, that is great that you can grow O. chlorotica without protection. I have tried a few, but they don't like to live past 5f.
How long have had your?
Martin Tversted (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sat, 12/10/2011 - 11:38pmThe challenge for the plants are not the winters, its the cool summers. They simply like it warmer during their growth periode than what we can expect here...
Trond Hoy
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/11/2011 - 2:42amYes, quite so but I'm willing to try ;D
Trond Hoy
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/11/2011 - 3:24amAnybody knowing the name of these Cacti found on the small island of El Gran Roque (Los Roques archipelago) last summer?
The first one is a Melocactus I believe:
The second is an Opuntia:
The third is completely unknown:
John P. Weiser
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/11/2011 - 7:53amI'd go quess melocactus macracanthos for the first. :)
I don't know that I could venture a guess on the others. :rolleyes:
John P. Weiser
Re: other cactus
Fri, 12/16/2011 - 11:05amThought you may like this Opuntia. :)
This is Opuntia macrocentra and is hardy for me but I have it placed near my south foundation. It will get frost damage if exposed to long stretches of sub 10F temperatures
I love the long spines, black with white tips, and the purple colored pads in the winter.
http://plants.usda.gov/java/profile?symbol=OPMA8
http://www.efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id=1&taxon_id=242415203
http://aggie-horticulture.tamu.edu/ornamentals/nativeshrubs/opuntiamacro...
Trond Hoy
Re: other cactus
Fri, 12/16/2011 - 11:40amYou are quite right, John!
Are bicoloured specimens/species common or rare BTW?
John P. Weiser
Re: other cactus
Fri, 12/16/2011 - 1:46pmTrond
Some of the differant clones of the Opuntia phaeacantha complex can display the same type of yellow and red bi-colored flowers.
In my experience you are more apt to find it occurring in non Opuntia species. Such as these Photos of the Echinocereus complex.
But there are many other cacti genera that show bi-colored flowers. I don't grow them due to lack of hardiness.
DesertZone (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sat, 12/17/2011 - 8:56amHere's one of the few I had, they did good but rotted under heavy snow fall one year or was it very cold? I think it was heavy snow. :rolleyes:

I was looking around and have a seedling/small plant from the one in the pic, could be hybrid? Does well in cold. I will try and get a pic and post.
PS I have lots of these on my place in AZ. I did not know they were there untill I went down in the drought. They grow right in the middle of dense bushes, probably for protection from collared peccaries.
Trond Hoy
Re: other cactus
Sat, 12/17/2011 - 10:55amJohn, I've seen pictures of some but never seen pictures of any bicoloured here.
This one (yours) takes the prize:
DesertZone (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/18/2011 - 8:02amOpuntia macrocentra/polyacantha cross, found two in the yard. both found very close were my old macrocantha grew. :-\

Only opuntia I have with long spines like these.
first one.
And the one I found yesterday after looking by the old plants.

cohan (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/18/2011 - 5:28pmThere are some online articles, which I might be able to find links to if pressed...lol Several months cold stratification is recommended by one study ( if I remember right, 3 months was better than one in the study).. I can attest to reasonable success from that strategy.. aging likely also, as Bob mentions... I have some seed several years old I may try.. another suggestion is GA3, and there is another (for me too complicated) approach that involves high temperatures , and those seeds which do not germinate quickly are then pierced .....
cohan (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/18/2011 - 5:51pmSame issue here, plus much colder winters than you have, though less wet...lol.. I've started my first cactus area, which is in a 'warm' microclimate on the property- southern exposure, fence behind, trees behind that, and another fence on west side, so it tends to be sheltered, warmer and drier than surrounding areas; so far a number of pots of seedlings sunk for the winter and one large pot with native O fragilis (which should not have any problems, its Echinocereus that will be tricky).. I'll also be using dark rocks to draw more warmth .. the possible drawback of this site/arrangement is that it retains less snowcover- so I shovelled more on them once there was enough around... they need all the help they can get once it gets to -30/-40.. experiments and observations yet to come!
I hope to try some sort of 'chollas' as well, a couple have been suggested as possibly hardy enough...
Richard T. Rodich
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/18/2011 - 6:02pmThe shrunken Echinocereus spp. seedlings are spending a second winter in the fridge before braving my winters outside.
Mark McDonough
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/18/2011 - 6:39pmBaby cacti seedlings are just soooOOOO cute. Rick, how do you handle them in the fridge? Don't they need more light? I'm interested in particular details about how you overwinter them in the fridge... and might such a technique be applicable to other plants?
cohan (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/18/2011 - 7:05pmWhile dormant, cacti do not need light, you just have to be careful re-acclimating them in spring; some people grow tender spp outdoors and winter plants in dark basements--just make sure they are dormant- cool/cold and dry for a while before...
No basement and no extra fridge space here, so my seedlings only got one winter indoors, we'll see what has survived by spring! I won't cry too much if the Echinocereus seedlings don't survive (not that I'll give up after one try)- my favourite plants and flowers for hardy cacti are Escobarias (esp missouriensis) and Pediocactus!
Richard T. Rodich
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/18/2011 - 9:06pmCohan is right. When practically any plant is dormant, you don't need light. Obviously, when a cactus shrinks down, you can be positive it is dormant. My fridge is kept very cold: if you put a cup of water in the back, it will freeze on top. And I am the only one here, so the door doesn't opened that often.
I was pretty apprehensive the first time I put these cactus in the fridge last season. I had only planted the seed the second week of July, and plants were so teensy, and even more so when they shrunk down! These pics were taken in mid August 2010:
http://nargs.org/smf/index.php?topic=501.msg5305#msg5305
Now compare that with this pic taken in mid July 2011, and how they shrunk to the image in my previous post, and you REALLY get the idea how teensy they were the first winter in the fridge.
Outside, pots sat under the roof eve for for several weeks before transferring to the fridge, and even then I put them in the fridge uncovered for a month before I enclosed them in a plastic bag. Materials stay this way until removal in spring. Remember that if you enclose materials and then put them in a colder temperature, you risk a lot of moisture condensation - in the soil and on the pot and plant surfaces. Water that was water vapor and innocuous, becomes liquid that can be dangerous and promote rot. The goal, in my opinion, is to reduce dessication, but not allow any free water liquid. If your plastic bag has water condensing on its inner surface, than the humidity is too high inside the bag.
I regularly overwinter other plants that I expect to not survive zone 4 winter (but still need a good winter) in the fridge. This also includes cuttings I root in the late summer, or cuttings that don't root until late summer/fall. These new plants, I have found through trial and error (well, error, really) just don't ready themselves for winter, even though they are outside, and even though they will be perfectly cold hardy next season.
When in the refrigerator, always err on the dry side. It really is amazing how dry plants survive when temps are low. Other seedlings that are in my fridge now, in their pots DRY are tender Gladiolus spp. There will be a few others that are still in the unheated garage.
cohan (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sun, 12/18/2011 - 10:52pmCute little things :)
I just kept my cactus seedlings under lights and more or less watered for the first winter. Many xerophytes seem not as concerned about moisture while young, so I usually don't worry about giving them a dry season the first year. of course if they are kept growing/not dormant you need reasonable light-- though I found with my Escobaria (vivipara and missouriensis) and Echinocereus seedlings (no great depth of experience here, this is all more or less one batch) were just fine under not fresh fluorescent lights for a year and half until I put them outside..
Richard T. Rodich
Re: other cactus
Mon, 12/19/2011 - 5:28amAfter sleeping on my last post, there was one thing I did forget:
The first time in the fridge, when the cactus was so excruciatingly tiny, in mid February I did take them out spritz them with perhaps a tablespoon of water per pot, let the surface dry, put them back in the sealed bag and back in the fridge. But I made sure there was no residual condensation.
I don't plan on doing this now (the second winter). Plants are much bigger.
My experience backs up Cohan's, regarding Escobaria. Seedlings did not require lots of light inside the house in the young growing stage. (I've germinated them in winter and late winter.) Although, I never grew them for more than a few months inside, before transferring outside.
John P. Weiser
Re: other cactus
Mon, 12/19/2011 - 6:21amThose are very attractively spined badboys. ;) I hope the flowers are something special too. :)
Cohan and Rick
Thank you for your input.
I just don't have the patience it takes to start cacti from seed. The years required for the plants to reach flowering size doesn't fit well with my need, for instant instant gratification. :)
cohan (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Mon, 12/19/2011 - 11:38amI can certainly understand that! However there is no place I can buy hardy cacti in person, and one place in Canada I know of where I can buy anything interesting (Beavercreek) by mail-- but with shipping etc, it ends up expensive (not complaining about the prices-- I can hardly imagine how any money can be made at what he charges for Pediocactus, knowing the slow growth rate!) and so far, out of my budget. Ordering from out of country- when not simply impossible- ends up more expensive yet with cost of paperwork, so thus far, seed is my only choice for anything other than Opuntia. I may some day save up for an order from Beavercreek (Pediocactus! so slow!)- but even then I will only be able to afford a few plants, and I really don't want one of those cactus gardens with one plant of each species...lol
On the plus side, the Escobarias and Echinocereus are not so slow :)
Michael Peden
escobaria mis.
Thu, 04/26/2012 - 8:48amHere's one that's fairly indelible; a lasting display: Escobaria missouriensis in seed. The fruit does not turn red until it has been through a winter so it takes nearlly a year from fertilization to viable seed.These were all grown from seed of a single plant in my garden so they may be children of E. missouriensis x E. vivipara or they "selfed". John Spain told me on a visit there that this is one of the best for New England. It's a great cactus. there is another excellent little plant in the photo: top left: Penstemon laricifolius. This one is ancient. They bloom together and its really quite something; small, but something. I may post a bunch of cacti on the desert thread. I'll try to get a bunch of seed of this on the exchange for 2012-2013. It's really easy to get going.
Richard T. Rodich
Re: other cactus
Thu, 04/26/2012 - 10:01amThose berries are very ornamental. I have to say I have never left my Escobaria vivipara berries attached into the winter because I collect them for seed, and now even to eat them ;D. I wonder though, if yours really need to get that red for seed to be ripe. I collect seed from E. vivipara when berries have a blush on them as in the pic below. At this stage they sometimes spontaneously pop off by themselves. Seed is completely viable at this time (no after ripening required), and no pretreatment needed either.
John P. Weiser
Re: other cactus
Thu, 04/26/2012 - 1:58pmI agree with Rick. They don't need to stay on the plant all winter to be viable. I believe they change to bright orange/red as a way to get the attention of birds and rodents. This would help insure seed dispersal of the left over fruits from the last season. The bigger test is to try and pick the fruit. If it is ripe it will be easy to detach.
Michael Peden
Re: other cactus
Fri, 04/27/2012 - 7:57amI treat seed of E. vivipara the same way; harvest in fall. This one though? I'll have to be more observant because I don't recall even seeing the fruit in fall despite having given at least a glance.
cohan (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Sun, 04/29/2012 - 1:10pmI don't know anything about the ripeness, but Panayoti a couple of weeks ago showed an E missouriensis (on Facebook) that was covered in berries which he said after that were shedding...
Richard T. Rodich
Re: other cactus
Sun, 06/17/2012 - 12:04pmFrom a gracious forum member, Maihuenia poeppigii cuttings, rooted in about 2.5 weeks:
John P. Weiser
Re: other cactus
Sun, 06/17/2012 - 2:41pmLooks like you are having good luck rooting those cuttings. They should do well for you.
cohan (not verified)
Re: other cactus
Mon, 06/18/2012 - 11:50pmLooking good, Rick! I think maybe I should put my seedlings out for the summer, but it would mean totally replacing the soil to bring them in for winter (too many critters out there..).. I've very sceptical about them surviving winter here, but will try some day...
Richard T. Rodich
Re: other cactus
Tue, 06/19/2012 - 1:48pmI have enough cuttings to try outside, too. (Not all were shown.) Every piece rooted. But I think it will be next winter for testing, not this coming one. Even my friend in northern Wisconsin, who seems to be able to grow anything, has problems with this one.
Pages